How Competitive Mystery Shopping Strengthens Your Market Positioning

On a routine store visit, Maya, an operations manager, noticed something she couldn’t explain. Her store was running smoothly, the team was engaged, and performance metrics looked fine. But as she pulled out of the lot, she glanced at a competitor across the street and saw the same thing she’d noticed on other days: customers entering steadily.

What were they doing that she wasn’t seeing?

She didn’t assume they were outperforming her team, but she knew customers would compare every experience they have. And without understanding what those experiences look like across the street, she only had part of the picture.

Enter competitive mystery shopping.

Mystery shopping competitors gives you the opportunity to experience their service, pricing approaches, digital touchpoints, and on-the-floor behaviors, offering invaluable insight into the market you operate in.

Why Brands Turn to Competitive Mystery Shops

Most operators have a strong grasp of what’s happening inside their own four walls. What’s harder to see is what customers experience everywhere else they shop. It’s also why 70% of companies now believe competitive intelligence is essential to their strategy. Here are some of the things they want to understand when they take a closer look at their competitors.

Seeing the Everyday Differences Customers Notice

Customers pick up on small details. A warmer greeting. A cleaner store. A smoother handoff. Operators use competitive mystery shopping to understand how those day-to-day differences show up across the street and which of them matter most.

Intouch Insight worked with several convenience store chains that wanted this clarity. They used IntouchShop^®, our mystery shopping program on nearby competitor locations to compare cleanliness, staff interaction, and overall feel. The insights helped them adjust specific in-store elements that influence first impressions.

Understanding What Customers Are Offered Elsewhere

When pricing, bundles, or service options change frequently, teams need to know exactly what customers hear in competitor stores. Seeing those conversations play out helps with positioning, training, and forecasting shifts in customer behavior.

Telecommunications providers rely on competitive mystery shops for this. They use the findings to compare how plans, promotions, and device packages are explained and to understand why certain competitors close sales more effectively. Some even identified top-performing sales staff in competitor stores and eventually hired them.

Experiencing Competitor Journeys Firsthand

A process that looks simple from the outside may feel completely different when you experience it as a real customer. Mystery shopping competitors helps operators understand the full journey from start to finish and compare how clearly and efficiently competitors guide customers along the way.

We ran an IntouchShop^® program for a financial services client who wanted this perspective. Shoppers applied for personal loans across nine competing lenders while capturing screenshots and messages at each step. The result was a complete, side-by-side view of how competitors handled applications, communication, and follow-up.

Learning What Matters in New Markets

Expectations shift from region to region. Brands entering new markets want to understand the service style, pace, trigger points, and store layout customers experience every day. Competitive intelligence through mystery shops provides that context so new locations open with a clear understanding of local norms.

What Competitive Mystery Shops Measure

Brands with better customer experience grow revenue 5.1 times faster than those that fall behind. This is  why operators mystery shop their competitors: to understand how to modify their CX strategy, execution, standard operating procedures, as well as identify training gaps. Here’s a few things they measure.

1. Customer Interaction Quality

How customers are greeted, how questions are answered, and how confidently staff communicate. Evaluators pay attention to tone, friendliness, attentiveness, and the level of professionalism throughout the interaction.

What about footage of your own shop interactions? Explore how video mystery shopping helps teams grow through actionable coaching insights.

2. Pricing and Promotion

How competitors position their pricing, what promotions or offers they present, and how clearly these options are explained. Secret shops look at advertised deals, in-store or online promotions, loyalty programs, bundles, fees, and any messaging that shapes a customer’s perception of value.

3. Sales Behaviors and Conversion Drivers

How effectively employees move a customer toward a purchase or commitment. Competitive mystery shops assess the quality of recommendations, upsell or cross-sell attempts, problem-solving, and the overall support offered during the decision process.

4. Execution and Accuracy

Whether the customer receives exactly what they requested, evaluators note order accuracy, proper documentation, accurate information, and whether commitments are fully delivered.

5. Environment and Presentation

What customers notice the moment they walk in. Mystery shops review cleanliness, organization, signage, product availability, merchandising, and the general presentation of the space.

6. Process Efficiency and Speed of Service

How quickly and smoothly the experience moves from start to finish. Secret shoppers watch for wait times, bottlenecks, unnecessary steps, staff coordination, and how easily a customer can complete their goal.

7. Digital Experience Quality

How well the competitor handles online actions such as booking, ordering, account setup, document submission, or navigating product information. Evaluators look for clarity, ease of use, and whether each digital step feels intuitive to a typical customer.

In retail-focused competitor shops, this often expands to include BOPIS (buy online, pick up in-store) and online-to-store returns. Shoppers assess how clearly pickup instructions are communicated, how smooth the transition is from digital to in-store, and whether returns are handled quickly and consistently. These two touchpoints reveal how well a competitor connects online expectations with in-store execution.

Curious about digital customer experiences? Discover more about the scope of online mystery shopping.

8. Compliance and Required Procedures

Whether staff follow critical standards such as age verification, identity checks, safety steps, documentation requirements, or industry-specific protocols. Competitive shops also assess how consistently these procedures are carried out.

9. Technology Used

What innovation competitors rely on to support service. Evaluators observe the use of kiosks, apps, payment systems, digital displays, check-in tools, scheduling platforms, and any technology that influences speed, clarity, or convenience.

Turning Competitive Intelligence into Better Results

Competitive mystery shopping becomes powerful when you use the findings to guide better decisions. Here’s what operators get excited about once they see the full picture:

• Identify quick wins – Identify simple fixes that make your experience feel faster, smoother, or more welcoming to customers.
• Spot opportunities worth paying attention to – Competitive shops highlight solutions that stand out in the market. Some may inspire changes, and others simply confirm that your current approach is already on the right track.
• Use insights to improve training – Real examples from the competitive landscape help teams understand what customers experience elsewhere and create stronger, more practical training moments.
• Validate or refine your strategy – Seeing how the market approaches service, pricing, digital flows, or product presentation helps confirm what is working and where adjusting your direction could create an advantage.
• Strengthen consistency across locations – Use insights to reinforce standards where your own stores need more alignment.
• Anticipate competitive shifts – See what’s evolving in your category before it gains momentum, giving you time to plan and stay ahead of customer needs.
• Guide smarter pilots and innovation – Use competitor analysis to decide what ideas to test, where to invest, and how to evolve your experience.
  
  

Here’s everything you need to know about how to make a generic mystery shopping evaluation into a GREAT one. 

Your Competitive Intelligence Through Mystery Shops

Intouch Insight has been a mystery shopping expert for more than 40 years, partnering with brands across retail, restaurants, convenience, hospitality, financial services, automotive, and more. We understand how customers think because we capture insights from the real interactions they have every day.

With a full suite of services like mystery shopping through IntouchShop^®, customer experience measurement, operational audits, CX analytics, and more, we give you competitive intelligence you can confidently act on.

In many markets, competitors are already evaluating each other to understand what customers are seeing. If you want the same, adding competitive mystery shopping to your strategy is a smart next step.

FAQs